As the global gambling industry evolves in 2025, operators face increasing regulatory pressures, heightened liabilities, and cross-border challenges. This research examines key trends in licensing, civil accountability, and enforcement strategies across major markets. Drawing from verified legal rulings and industry data, it offers practical guidance for navigating these complexities while identifying growth opportunities.
Download presentation (.pdf)
Download research (.pdf)
Global Gambling Law 2025: Winning in a Liability-Heavy, Cross-Border Minefield
Courts increasingly hold operators liable for player losses based on collected data. In Sweden, the Supreme Court’s July 2025 ruling in T 607-24 ordered Betsson to refund €527,395 to a VIP with gambling issues, establishing “imputed knowledge” from analytics.
In the UK, the High Court’s January 2025 decision in RTM v. Sky Betting & Gaming invalidated GDPR consent for vulnerable gamblers, opening data-processing liability paths. These create duties rooted in data and contract law beyond fines.
Grey-market profits face retroactive risks in the EU. Courts in the Netherlands (April 2024), Austria (consistent rulings), and Germany (pre-2021 refunds) void unlicensed contracts, triggering restitution.
Malta’s Bill 55 shield faces EU infringement proceedings initiated June 2025, with Advocate General Emiliou’s September 2025 opinion in C-440/23 weakening protections.
In the U.S., post-2018 Murphy v. NCAA patchwork allows litigation despite regulation. Michigan’s July 2025 Davis v. BetMGM affirmed common-law suits for fraud; contrastingly, the Third Circuit’s April 2025 Antar v. BetMGM rejected general duties for compulsive losses.
The D.C. Circuit’s 2023 West Flagler v. Haaland upheld Florida’s hub-and-spoke tribal model. Federal calls, like 50 attorneys general’s August 2025 UIGEA push, target offshore sites.
Advertising faces youth-protection clamps. The UK’s ASA enforced “strong appeal” tests, sanctioning Midnite (September 2025) for AI footballer parody and Ladbrokes (December 2022) for Premier League players.
Italy’s Dignity Decree ban faces EU challenge. Bonuses tighten: UK’s 10x wagering cap from December 2025; Sweden’s VIP liability; Ontario fines like BetMGM $110,000.
Cross-border wars intensify. Curaçao’s December 2024 Dutch Supreme Court ruling holds master licensees liable for subs. U.S. Wire Act limited to sports per 2021 First Circuit.
Financial blockades standard: U.S. UIGEA/Reg GG/MCC 7995; Australia ACMA ISP blocks; Spain DGOJ €77m fines H2 2024; Brazil SPA/Anatel partnerships.
Regionally: Brazil’s January 2025 regime; Germany’s €1,000 limit; India’s 2025 ban challenge; Ontario’s model upheld May 2024, liquidity affirmed November 2025; Argentina’s provincial patchwork; India’s ban faces Supreme Court deferral to 2026; Macau/Hong Kong monopolies; Japan’s IRs tied to 2025 Expo; South Africa’s 2024 Remote Gambling Bill.
Operators must embed RG algorithms, fund contingencies, and target licensed expansions like Brazil/Ontario while exiting high-risk greys. This framework turns liability into moats via compliance.
The 2025 Regulatory Reset — Major Markets Opt for Licensing
Governments increasingly license online gambling for tax revenue and protections, creating varied models.
Brazil’s National Roll-Out Adds 215m Consumers
Brazil established federal licensing for sports betting and casinos under Law No. 14,790/2023, effective January 1, 2025. The SPA/MF oversees payments, advertising, and standards.
The STF shaped limits, invalidating provisions.
Ontario’s “Conduct & Manage” Blueprint Outperforms Monopoly Provinces
Ontario’s public-private model, upheld in Mohawk Council v. iGaming Ontario (May 2024), confirms provincial control. November 2025 appeal affirmed international liquidity.
Civil Liability Explosion — From Regulatory Fines to Court-Ordered Refunds
Courts empower consumers, shifting risks to balance sheets.
Data-Driven Duty of Care: Sweden and UK Create Imputed-Knowledge Standard
Sweden’s July 2025 T 607-24 ordered €527,395 refund under Contracts Act for imputed knowledge. UK’s January 2025 RTM v. Sky Betting invalidated GDPR consent.
Contract Nullity for Unlicensed Play: Netherlands, Austria, and Germany
| Jurisdiction | Key Development | Legal Basis & Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Netherlands | April 2024 courts ordered refunds for pre-2021 unlicensed activity. | Contracts void for public policy violation. |
| Austria | Supreme Court consistently orders refunds for unlicensed operators. | Enforcement hurdles, but principle holds. |
| Germany | Federal Court orders pre-2021 refunds. | Contracts void under prior prohibition. |
Michigan’s July 2025 Davis v. BetMGM allows common-law claims. Third Circuit’s April 2025 Antar v. BetMGM rejects general duties.
Cross-Border Enforcement Wars — Brussels I vs. Bill 55 & Curaçao’s U-Turn
Internet borderlessness sparks clashes.
EU Showdown: Commission v. Malta Timeline & Probable Outcomes
Malta’s Bill 55 faces June 2025 infringement. AG Emiliou’s September 2025 C-440/23 opinion favors consumers.
Curaçao Master Licence Liability After Dutch Supreme Court Ruling
December 2024 ruling holds master licensees liable.
Wire Act & UIGEA: First Circuit Limits, AGs Push Expansion
2021 First Circuit limits Wire Act to sports. 50 AGs’ August 2025 UIGEA call targets offshore.
Stricter rules protect minors.
“Strong Appeal” Test: ASA Case Studies (Midnite, Ladbrokes)
| Case/Operator | Date | Violation & Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Dribble Media Ltd (t/a Midnite) | Sept 17, 2025 | AI parody of Trent Alexander-Arnold appealed to under-18s. |
| LC International Ltd (t/a Ladbrokes) | Dec 21, 2022 | Featured Coutinho, Lingard, Koulibaly. |
Bonus & VIP Restrictions: UK 10× Cap, Swedish VIP Liability, Ontario Fines
UK’s 10x cap effective December 2025. Sweden’s VIP liability. Ontario fined BetMGM $110,000, DraftKings $100,000.
Platform & Affiliate Co-Liability
UK CAP Code holds publishers jointly responsible.
Disrupting illegal models.
UIGEA, Regulation GG, and MCC 7995 in the U.S.
UIGEA prohibits restricted transactions; Reg GG requires blocking; MCC 7995 identifies gambling.
Global Blocking Scorecard: Australia, Spain, Brazil
| Country | Regulator | Method | Key Actions & Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Australia | ACMA | ISP Blocking | Blocks offshore sites. |
| Spain | DGOJ | Fines & Blocks | €77m fines H2 2024. |
| Brazil | SPA/MF & Anatel | Payment & ISP | Blocks unlicensed. |
Region-Specific Deep Dives
Post-2018 Murphy v. NCAA. 2023 West Flagler validated hub-and-spoke.
Gambelli/Placanica set proportionality. Malta crisis per 2025 proceedings.
November 2024 Gibson v. Betfair rejects general duty. January 2025 RTM opens GDPR front.
Ontario model upheld; November 2025 liquidity affirmed.
Brazil 2025 regime. Argentina provincial.
India’s 2025 ban challenged. Macau/Hong Kong restrictive. Japan IRs for 2025 Expo.
2024 Bill aims to regulate remote gambling.
Strategic Playbook — Surviving and Thriving in 2026-2028
Integrate legal foresight.
Licence & Liability Matrix: Where to Expand, Where to Exit
| Region/Jurisdiction | Market Status | Key Opportunity | Primary Risk | Strategic Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brazil | Regulated | 215M market. | Evolving regs. | Prioritize license. |
| Ontario, Canada | Mature | Liquidity. | Ad fines. | Audit marketing. |
| EU (ex-Malta) | Fragmented | Player base. | Refunds. | Book liabilities. |
| Malta (EU) | Hub | Framework. | Infringement. | Explore insurance. |
| United States | State-by-State | Growth. | Litigation. | Tighten T&Cs. |
| India | Prohibition | Potential if overturned. | Uncertainty. | Monitor challenge. |
| South Africa | Pending | Opportunity if passes. | May not pass. | Monitor Bill. |
“Responsible by Design”: Embedding Real-Time RG Algorithms
Automate monitoring for risky behaviors.
Hedge EU grey risks.
M&A Targets: Provincial Licensed Assets & Tribal Tech Partnerships
Acquire in Argentina; partner tribes per West Flagler.
Appendices
| Case Name | Jurisdiction | Court | Year | Key Holding & Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Murphy v. NCAA | US | Supreme | 2018 | Struck down PASPA. |
| Davis v. BetMGM | US | Michigan Supreme | 2025 | Allows common-law claims. |
| West Flagler v. Haaland | US | D.C. Circuit | 2023 | Validates hub-and-spoke. |
| T 607-24 (‘Nätkasinot’) | Sweden | Supreme | 2025 | Imputed knowledge refunds. |
| RTM v. Sky Betting & Gaming | UK | High | 2025 | Invalid GDPR consent. |
| Gambelli and Others | EU | CJEU | 2003 | Restrictions must be proportionate. |
| Mohawk Council v. iGaming Ontario | Canada | Ontario Superior | 2024 | Upholds model. |
| Betfair v. Western Australia | Australia | High | 2008 | Invalidates protectionist laws. |
| Jurisdiction | Key Rule/Standard | Enforcement Body | Recent Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK | “Strong appeal” test. | ASA | Midnite Sept 2025; Ladbrokes Dec 2022. |
| Italy | Ad ban (‘Dignity Decree’). | AGCOM | EU challenge. |
| Germany | Athlete ban; watershed. | GGL | GlüNeuRStV framework. |
| Canada (Ontario) | Athlete ban Feb 2024. | AGCO | Fines for inducements. |
| Brazil | Ban to children. | STF | Nov 2024 injunction. |
- ACMA: Australian Communications and Media Authority
- AGCO: Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario
- ASA: Advertising Standards Authority (UK)
- CJEU: Court of Justice of the European Union
- DGOJ: Dirección General de Ordenación del Juego (Spain)
- GDPR: General Data Protection Regulation
- GGL: Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (Germany)
- iGO: iGaming Ontario
- IGA: Interactive Gambling Act 2001 (Australia)
- IGRA: Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (US)
- IR: Integrated Resort
- LCCP: Licence Conditions and Codes of Practice (UK)
- MGA: Malta Gaming Authority
- PASPA: Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (US)
- SPA/MF: Secretaria de Prêmios e Apostas / Ministry of Finance (Brazil)
- STF: Supremo Tribunal Federal (Brazil)
- UIGEA: Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (US)
Discussion
Findings highlight liability as a core risk, with data analytics now a double-edged sword. Compared to pre-2021 greys, regulated markets like Brazil/Ontario offer stability but demand RG integration.
EU refunds cascade per Emiliou underscores mutual recognition crises. Limitations: Report focuses on verified 2025 data; future shifts (e.g., India challenge) may alter landscapes.
Implications: Operators face balance-sheet hits but can build moats via compliance tech.
Conclusions
Key findings: Heightened duties, refund risks, and blocks dominate 2025. Implications: Prioritize licensed markets, embed RG.
Future: Monitor India/Japan developments; advocate balanced regs. Recommendations: Fund contingencies, partner strategically, automate monitoring.
Sources
This research was compiled from the following verified sources:
- Swedish Supreme Court (2025) – Case T 607-24 Judgment – https://www.domstol.se/nyheter/2025/07/ett-spelbolag-ska-aterbetala-drygt-500-000-euro-till-en-spelare-med-allvarliga-spelproblem/
- Rechtbank Overijssel (2024) – ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2024:2079 – https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/details?id=ECLI:NL:RBOVE:2024:2079
- DLA Piper (2025) – Advocate General Opinion on Gambling Losses – https://www.dlapiper.com/en-us/insights/blogs/mse-today/2025/advocate-general-of-the-cjeu-issues-opinion-on-claims-for-gambling-losses
- Mayer Brown (2024) – Corporate Aspects of Brazil’s Esports Betting Law – https://www.mayerbrown.com/en/insights/publications/2024/02/the-corporate-tax-and-regulatory-aspects-of-brazils-esports-betting-law
- Michigan Supreme Court (2025) – Davis v. BetMGM Opinion – https://www.courts.michigan.gov/4a1688/siteassets/case-documents/uploads/opinions/final/sct/166281_94_01.pdf
- Third Circuit (2025) – Antar v. BetMGM – https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca3/24-1364/24-1364-2025-04-28.html
- ASA (2025) – Ruling on Dribble Media Ltd t/a Midnite – https://www.asa.org.uk/rulings/dribble-media-ltd-g25-1300959-dribble-media-ltd.html
- ASA (2022) – Ruling on LC International Ltd t/a Ladbrokes – https://www.asa.org.uk/rulings/lc-international-ltd.html
- IMGL (2025) – Brazil Gambling Sector Issues – https://www.imgl.org/publications/imgl-magazine-volume-3-no-1/gambling-sector-and-federation-issues-in-brazil/
- A&O Shearman (2025) – High Court Rules on Consent for Profiling – https://www.aoshearman.com/en/insights/ao-shearman-on-data/high-court-rules-on-standard-of-consent-required-for-profiling-and-direct-marketing
- Lexology (2025) – Online Casino Case – https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=0469c458-f97a-4e5b-aa9c-a5636f4faba0
- Yogonet (2024) – Austrian Supreme Court Orders Return of Winnings – https://www.yogonet.com/international/news/2024/08/09/74803-austrian-supreme-court-orders-gambler-to-return-partial-winnings-to-unlicensed-operator-in-landmark-case
- EAPIL (2025) – Commission Opens Infringement Against Malta – https://eapil.org/2025/06/19/commission-opens-infringement-procedure-against-malta-for-failing-to-comply-with-the-brussels-i-bis-regulation/
- DLA Piper (2025) – Advocate General Opinion – https://www.dlapiper.com/en-us/insights/blogs/mse-today/2025/advocate-general-of-the-cjeu-issues-opinion-on-claims-for-gambling-losses
- SCOTUSblog (2018) – Murphy v. NCAA – https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/case-files/murphy-v-national-collegiate-athletic-association-2/
- Justia (2023) – West Flagler v. Haaland – https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cadc/21-5265/21-5265-2023-06-30.html
- NAAG (2025) – 50 AGs Urge DOJ Action – https://www.naag.org/policy-letter/50-state-and-territory-attorneys-general-urge-doj-action-on-illegal-offshore-gambling/
- ASA (2022) – Ladbrokes Ruling – https://www.asa.org.uk/rulings/lc-international-ltd.html
- European Gaming (2025) – Italy’s Ad Ban to ECJ – https://europeangaming.eu/portal/latest-news/2025/04/07/179942/italys-gambling-ad-ban-moves-to-eu-court-of-justice/
- Gambling Commission (2025) – Safer Promotions – https://www.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/news/article/gambling-promotions-to-be-safer-and-simpler
- AGCO (2025) – BetMGM Penalty – https://finance.yahoo.com/news/agco-issues-110-000-penalties-150600641.html
- NEXT.io (2024) – Dutch Supreme Court Ruling – https://next.io/news/regulation/dutch-supreme-court-master-licensees-liable/
- Justia (2021) – NH Lottery v. Rosen – https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca1/19-1835/19-1835-2021-01-20.html
- Federal Reserve (2017) – Regulation GG – https://www.federalreserve.gov/supervisionreg/regggcg.htm
- ACMA (2025) – Blocked Websites – https://www.acma.gov.au/blocked-gambling-websites
- Vixio (2025) – Spanish Regulator Fines – https://www.vixio.com/insights/gc-austrian-court-calls-online-casino-contracts-invalid-orders-refunds
- iGaming Brazil (2025) – Anatel Partnership – https://igamingbrazil.com/en/legislation-en/2025/11/03/partnership-between-anatel-and-spa-mf-has-already-blocked-approximately-23000-illegal-gambling-websites/
- Clifford Chance (2021) – German Interstate Treaty – https://www.cliffordchance.com/content/dam/cliffordchance/briefings/2021/07/new-german-interstate-treaty-on-gambling-entered-into-effect.pdf
- Outlook India (2025) – Online Gaming Hearing Deferred – https://respawn.outlookindia.com/esports/esports-news/online-gaming-law-hearing-pushed-by-supreme-court-to-2026
- Blakes (2024) – Ontario iGaming Model – https://www.blakes.com/insights/ontario-s-igaming-model-complies-with-criminal-code-court-rules/
- Blakes (2025) – Ontario Appeal Liquidity – https://www.blakes.com/insights/ontario-court-of-appeal-green-lights-access-to-international-pooled-liquidity-for-online-gaming-in-o/
- ICLG (2025) – Gambling Laws Argentina – https://iclg.com/practice-areas/gambling-laws-and-regulations/argentina
- Wikipedia (2025) – Gambling in Hong Kong/Macau – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambling_in_Hong_Kong
- Altenar (2025) – Japan IRs – https://altenar.com/en-us/blog/gambling-laws-in-hong-kong-the-rules-restrictions-and-future-possibilities/
- Gov.za (2024) – Remote Gambling Bill – https://www.gov.za/documents/bills/remote-gambling-bill-b11-2024-16-apr-2024
- Zerafa Advocates (2025) – Malta Bill 55 – https://www.zerafa.com.mt/beyond-the-headlines-what-article-56a-really-means-for-gaming-in-malta/
- IMGL (2025) – Brazil Issues – https://www.imgl.org/publications/imgl-magazine-volume-3-no-1/gambling-sector-and-federation-issues-in-brazil/
- AGCO (2022) – DraftKings Penalty – https://www.agco.ca/en/news/agco-issues-100000-monetary-penalties-draft-kings-canada-alleged-advertising-and-inducement
- ASA (2025) – Remit: Social Media – https://www.asa.org.uk/advice-online/remit-social-media.html
- EUR-Lex (2003) – Gambelli Case – https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:62001CJ0243
- UK Judiciary (2024) – Gibson v. Betfair – https://www.judiciary.uk/live-hearings/gibson-appellant-v-tse-malta-lp-t-a-betfair-respondent/
- High Court of Australia (2008) – Betfair v. Western Australia – https://www.hcourt.gov.au/sites/default/files/assets/publications/judgment-summaries/2008/hca11-2008-03-27.pdf
